Top Neighborhoods to Live in Long Island, NY

By: ROS Team

Share the Post:

Long Island, NY, is a beautiful island on which a third of New Yorkers call home. Whether you’re a young professional living on your own, a couple trying to start a family, or a commuter with roommates, there’s a Long Island neighborhood that suits everyone.

Here Are Some of the Best Neighborhoods on Long Island:

1. Massapequa
2. Commack
3. Plainview
4. Huntington
5. Islip
6. Smithtown
7. Stony Brook
8. Merrick
9. Jericho
10. Roslyn
11. Bellmore
12. Great Neck Gardens


According to Zillow, the average selling price of a home in Massapequa is $652,524. The prices of properties in Massapequa have risen 11.2% since 2021.

Massapequa is a great neighborhood for families thanks to its high-ranking school system. There is a variety of outdoor leisure activities in this area. Massapequa Cove, a favorite fishing place in the New York City area, is just a short distance away from the local parks. Any way you look at it, Massapequa is an upscale neighborhood with access to leisure and learning.


Commack is a popular neighborhood where celebrities like Rosie O’Donnell and Randy Rainbow call home. The average price for a property in Commack is $708,872. Commack is the former home of the Long Island Arena, and the area is still home to many athletes. As a small town with a sparse suburban feel and well-known restaurants such as ​​​​Outback Steakhouse, Spicy Home Tasty, and Paradise Pizza.


Plainview is one of the wealthiest neighborhoods on Long Island; as of April 2022, the average price of a property in Plainview was $790,000. This marks an increase of over 16% since 2021. Despite the higher cost, Plainview has some incredible real estate options to choose from.


Huntington is a town in Long Island’s Suffolk County. The typical listing price for a property in Huntington, New York, was $796,900 as of April 2022. This is an increase of 16% since 2021.

Huntington has several boutiques and local markets, restaurants, and a vibrant nightlife.


Islip is a coastal community with a relatively low population density. The average price of a house in Islip was $520,000 as of April 2022, representing an 11.7% percent increase since 2021.

People who enjoy spending time on the water or simply taking in the beauty are drawn to Islip’s beaches. This neighborhood has an overall laid-back ambiance, great schools, and booming nightlife.


Smithtown has a strong sense of community despite its small size. It’s located about 50 miles north of Manhattan and in the heart of the North Shore. On average, a one-bedroom apartment in Smithtown will rent for around $2,934 a month. Smithtown is known for its artisan brews, restaurants, and unique shops. It also has many parks, including Caleb Smith State Park.

Stony Brook

Stony Brook’s beauty once made it a popular tourist destination Today, the region has also become a popular place to live with access to great schools and a nearby college for continuing education opportunities.

On average, one-bedroom apartments in Stony Brook rent for around $2,310 a month. The average cost of rent has remained stable since 2021.


Located on Long Island’s southernmost tip, Merrick is popular for its beaches and sunshine. Merrick offers the best of both worlds: great suburban living and proximity to New York City (the city is just a 45-minute train ride from the neighborhood). Elegant homes, seaside activities, and lively nightlife are also part of the area’s appeal. Merrick is one of New York City’s safest boroughs, and the average house price is $708,851.


Despite being fewer than 30 miles from Manhattan, Jericho is a sleepy hamlet with a population of only 13,000 people. Jericho’s small town vibe attracts visitors and prospective residents alike because of its tranquility and high-performing schools. Homes in Jericho have an average monthly rent of $2,227 for a 12 month lease term.


Roslyn is another popular community on Long Island. Despite the median $500,000 price, many homes in Roslyn are priced in the $750,000 to $1 million range. The houses are lovely, the school system is excellent, and the area is safe.


Bellmore is a good neighborhood option if you value a quieter community atmosphere. One of the area’s most prominent attractions is Jones Beach Park, a Long Island beach that many consider as one of the greatest in the state of New York.

Bellmore renters can expect to pay an average of $1,800 a month for a one-bedroom apartment. The average rent price has remained steady since 2021.

Great Neck Gardens

If you want to live in an older but beautiful neighborhood, Great Neck Gardens is a top choice. This community’s leadership has put in a lot of effort to preserve the neighborhood’s history, as evidenced by the array of architectural styles scattered throughout the neighborhood.

Great Neck Gardens has Allenwood Park, which boasts a pond, walking paths, and tennis courts that residents can enjoy year round. The average monthly rent for an apartment in Great Neck Gardens is around $3,370 a month.

The Bottom Line

Long Island is a great place to live. Keep in mind that we only spotlighted some of Long Island’s best neighborhoods; there are many more to choose from. Reach out to a real estate agent or broker for more information about available real estate in Long Island.

Related Article:

Safest Neighborhoods In Brooklyn
Best Neighborhoods to Live in Manhattan
Best Neighborhoods In Brooklyn For Families
Quietest Neighborhoods In NYC
Best Pet Friendly Neighborhoods In New York City