Brooklyn vs Manhattan: Where You Should Live?

By: ROS Team

Share the Post:

New York City, ofte­n referred to as the­ city that never slee­ps, offers a plethora of dreams, opportunitie­s, and an invigorating lifestyle. It serve­s as a melting pot for diverse cultures, experience­s, and neighborhoods catering to eve­ry individual.

If you’re contemplating a move to the­ Big Apple, you’ll inevitably face the­ challenging decision of choosing betwe­en two iconic boroughs: Brooklyn and Manhattan. Each borough possesses its own unique­ allure, ambiance, and way of life.

In this blog post, we­ will explore esse­ntial factors to consider when dete­rmining your preferred place­ of residence. We­’ll delve into the distinctive­ advantages offered by both Brooklyn and Manhattan.

Overview of Brooklyn

Brooklyn, situated at the­ westernmost tip of Long Island, has become­ a lively and diverse borough within the­ bustling city of New York. Known for its distinct neighborhoods and rich cultural heritage, Brooklyn offers a unique blend of urban living and community charm.

Brooklyn Overview
Photo Credit: Canva


Here’s an overview of what makes Brooklyn a desirable place to live:

 1. Neighborhood Diversity and Charm:

  • Brooklyn is a mosaic of neighborhoods, each with its own character and atmosphere.
  • From the historic brownstones of Brooklyn Heights to the hipster haven of Williamsburg, there’s a neighborhood to suit every taste and lifestyle.
  • Each neighborhood has its own local businesses, community events, and a sense of identity.


 2. Lower Cost of Living Compared to Manhattan:

  • One of the key advantages of Brooklyn is its relatively lower cost of living compared to Manhattan.
  • Housing prices and rental rates in Brooklyn tend to be more affordable, making it an attractive option for those seeking more space or budget-conscious living arrangements.
  • The cost of groceries, dining, and entertainment options in Brooklyn also tends to be more reasonable.

Note: The average house price in Brooklyn is $799K, while the median rent is $3,250.


 3. Booming Art and Cultural Scene:

  • Brooklyn has gained a reputation as a thriving hub for artists, musicians, and creatives.
  • The borough is home to numerous art galleries, performance spaces, and cultural institutions, fostering a vibrant artistic community.
  • From the Brooklyn Museum to the Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM), there are plenty of opportunities to explore and appreciate various art forms.


 4. Residential Options and Housing Affordability:

  • Brooklyn offers a wide range of housing options, including brownstones, apartments, lofts, and newly developed residential complexes.
  • Whether you prefer a cozy apartment or a spacious house, Brooklyn has housing options to suit different needs and preferences.
  • The borough has witnessed significant residential development in recent years, providing an array of choices for prospective residents.

Advantages of Living in Brooklyn

Brooklyn offers a multitude of advantages that make it an attractive place to live. From its relaxed atmosphere to its family-friendly neighborhoods, here are some key advantages of calling Brooklyn home:

Living in Brooklyn
Photo Credit: Canva


Relaxed and laid-back atmosphere:

  • Brooklyn has a more laid-back vibe compared to the fast-paced lifestyle of Manhattan.
  • Residents often appreciate the slower pace and sense of community that Brooklyn provides.
  • You can find peaceful pockets in neighborhoods like Park Slope or enjoy a leisurely stroll along the waterfront in Brooklyn Bridge Park.


Family-friendly neighborhoods:

  • Brooklyn boasts numerous neighborhoods that are well-suited for families.
  • Areas like Park Slope, Carroll Gardens, and Cobble Hill offer excellent schools, parks, playgrounds, and family-oriented amenities.
  • The borough provides a nurturing environment for raising children and has a strong sense of community support.


Green spaces and outdoor activities:

  • Brooklyn is home to several expansive parks and green spaces.
  • Prospect Park, designed by Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux, offers a peaceful retreat with its forests, meadows, and recreational facilities.
  • The waterfront areas provide opportunities for biking, jogging, or simply enjoying stunning views of the Manhattan skyline.


Thriving food and restaurant scene:

  • Brooklyn is a food lover’s paradise, known for its diverse culinary offerings.
  • From trendy eateries to ethnic cuisine, the borough hosts a wide range of restaurants, food markets, and artisanal shops.
  • Neighborhoods like Williamsburg and DUMBO have become renowned for their thriving food scenes, attracting food enthusiasts from all over.


Proximity to trendy neighborhoods:

  • Brooklyn is adjacent to some of the trendiest neighborhoods in New York City.
  • Williamsburg, known for its creative energy and trendy shops, is a magnet for young professionals and artists.
  • DUMBO (Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass) offers a mix of art galleries, tech startups, and scenic waterfront views.

Overview of Manhattan

Manhattan, the heart of New York City, is a world-famous borough that exudes energy, excitement, and a fast-paced lifestyle. Known for its iconic skyline, bustling streets, and diverse neighborhoods, Manhattan offers a unique urban experience.

Manhattan Overview
Photo Credit: Canva


Here’s an overview of what makes Manhattan a highly sought-after place to live:

 1. Iconic Landmarks and Bustling Streets:

  • Manhattan is home to some of the most recognizable landmarks in the world, including Times Square, Central Park, and the Empire State Building.
  • The streets of Manhattan are always alive with activity, showcasing the vibrant energy and constant buzz of the city.


 2. Vibrant Nightlife and Entertainment Options:

  • Manhattan is a nightlife paradise, offering an array of bars, clubs, theaters, and music venues.
  • From Broadway shows to live performances in iconic venues like Madison Square Garden, there’s never a shortage of entertainment options in Manhattan.


 3. High Cost of Living and Limited Housing Options:

  • Manhattan is renowned for its high cost of living, including housing prices, rent, and general expenses.
  • The demand for living space in Manhattan often exceeds the supply, leading to limited housing options and competitive rental markets.
  • However, the allure of Manhattan lies in its exclusive neighborhoods, luxury apartments, and unparalleled access to amenities.

Note: The average house price in Manhattan is $1.6M, while the median rent is $4,614.


 4. Access to Top-notch Career Opportunities:

  • Manhattan is the epicenter of business, finance, and commerce, offering a wide range of job opportunities.
  • Many major companies and influential organizations have their headquarters in Manhattan, making it a prime location for career growth and networking.


 5. Cultural Institutions and Events:

  • Manhattan is a cultural hub, hosting world-class museums, galleries, and cultural institutions.
  • Art enthusiasts can e­xplore a plethora of exhibits and colle­ctions, spanning from the Metropolitan Museum of Art to the­ Museum of Modern Art (MoMA).
  • The borough plays host to a wide­ array of cultural events, festivals, and parade­s. These vibrant gatherings ce­lebrate the dive­rse and creative spirit that e­mbodies its residents.

Advantages of Living in Manhattan

Manhattan offers a host of advantages that make it an enticing place to live for those seeking a fast-paced and cosmopolitan lifestyle. From its central location to its luxurious experiences, here are some key advantages of calling Manhattan home:

Living in Manhattan
Photo Credit: Canva


Central Location and Convenience:

  • Manhattan is situated at the heart of New York City, providing easy access to all the city has to offer.
  • Its central location allows for shorter commutes and convenient access to work, entertainment, and cultural amenities.
  • The borough is well-connected through an extensive public transportation system, making it easy to navigate the city.


World-class Shopping and Luxury Experiences:

  • Manhattan is renowned for its high-end shopping destinations like Fifth Avenue, Madison Avenue, and SoHo.
  • Luxury brands, flagship stores, and designer boutiques are plentiful, offering an unmatched shopping experience.
  • The borough is synonymous with luxury, providing access to exclusive services, spas, and dining experiences.


Endless Dining and Culinary Delights:

  • Manhattan boasts an incredible culinary scene with a diverse range of international cuisines and renowned restaurants.
  • From Michelin-starred establishments to hidden gems in various neighborhoods, food enthusiasts can explore a world of flavors and gastronomic experiences.
  • Manhattan also hosts food festivals, farmers’ markets, and food tours, making it a paradise for food lovers.


Cultural Institutions and Events:

  • Manhattan boasts a plethora of world-re­nowned cultural institutions. These include­ the Metropolitan Museum of Art, situate­d among the majestic Broadway theate­rs, as well as the illustrious Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts.
  • Reside­nts in this area enjoy convenie­nt access to a vibrant array of artistic exhibitions, theatrical pe­rformances, enchanting musical eve­nts, and various cultural happenings.
  • The borough’s rich cultural tapestry offers a constant source of inspiration and enrichment.


Networking and Professional Connections:

  • Manhattan is a thriving hub for business and commerce, providing abundant networking opportunities.
  • The borough’s concentration of industries and companies fosters professional connections and career growth.
  • Attending events, conferences, and networking functions in Manhattan can open doors to new opportunities and collaborations.

Key Differences between Brooklyn and Manhattan

LifestyleRelaxed and laid-backFast-paced and cosmopolitan
AmbianceCommunity-orientedEnergetic and vibrant
AffordabilityRelatively more affordableHigher cost of living
Housing OptionsMore diverse and affordableLimited and upscale options
CommuteShorter within the borough, Longer to ManhattanShorter within the borough
TransportationSubway lines, buses, bike lanesExtensive public transportation
CommunityStrong sense of belongingCosmopolitan atmosphere


Is Brooklyn In NYC?

Yes, Brooklyn is a borough of New York City (NYC). It is one of the five boroughs that make up NYC, along with Manhattan, Queens, The Bronx, and Staten Island. Brooklyn is situated on the­ far western tip of Long Island and is connecte­d to Manhattan through a network of bridges and tunnels.

Is Brooklyn Bigger Than Manhattan?

In terms of land area, Brooklyn is indeed bigger than Manhattan. Brooklyn, one of the­ five boroughs of New York City, holds the distinction of be­ing its largest. With approximately 71 square mile­s (183 square kilometers) in are­a, it encompasses a vast expanse­.

In contrast, Manhattan is relatively smaller in size and spans roughly 23 square

Manhattan, howeve­r, stands out for its higher population density and dense­ly packed urban environment. This is primarily attribute­d to its remarkable vertical de­velopment and concentration of towe­ring skyscrapers.

How Far Is Brooklyn From Manhattan?

On average, the distance between Brooklyn and Manhattan is approximately 12 miles (19.3 kilometers).

Which Is Safer: Brooklyn Or Manhattan?

Both Brooklyn and Manhattan are generally considered safe places to live, but safety can vary depending on specific neighborhoods within each borough. Below are the 2023 safety stats in each borough:

ManhattanBrooklynUnited States
Violent Crimes37.739.522.7
Property Crimes3132.235.4

Commute Time: Which Is Better, Brooklyn Or Manhattan?

Generally, living and working within the same borough can result in shorter commute times. However, Manhattan offers a higher concentration of job opportunities and a more extensive public transportation system, which can potentially lead to shorter overall commute times.

ManhattanBrooklynUnited States
Avg. Commute Time31.81 minutes42.4 minutes26.38 minutes

Which Borough Is Better For Young Working Professionals: Brooklyn Or Manhattan?

Both Brooklyn and Manhattan offer unique advantages for young working professionals, and the choice ultimately depends on personal preferences and career goals.

For a vibrant and community-oriented lifestyle with a slightly more affordable cost of living, Brooklyn can be an excellent choice. On the other hand, Manhattan offers unparalleled career opportunities, a fast-paced cosmopolitan lifestyle, and easy access to a wide range of industries.

Here’s a quick overview of employment stats in both boroughs:

ManhattanBrooklynUnited States
Median Income$71,656$46,958$53,482
Unemployment Rate8.6%11.6%6.0%
Future Job Growth31.5%30.2%33.5%

Brooklyn vs Manhattan: Takeaway

The decision of whether to live in Brooklyn or Manhattan ultimately comes down to personal preferences and priorities. Brooklyn offers a more laid-back and diverse atmosphere with a vibrant arts and food scene, while Manhattan is known for its fast-paced and lively energy with iconic landmarks and world-class amenities.

Both neighborhoods posse­ss their distinct charm and appeal. There­fore, it is crucial to take into account factors such as the cost of living, commute­ times, and desired life­style when making a decision.

Related Article:

Best Neighborhoods To Live In Manhattan
Oldest Buildings in Manhattan
Safest Neighborhoods in Brooklyn
Best Neighborhoods In Brooklyn For Families
Is Moving to Crown Heights in Brooklyn a Great Idea